Jury awards $1.25 million to Pine Plains family in school racial harassment suit

PINE PLAINS — A federal court jury decided last week that the Pine Plains Central School District must pay $1.25 million to a local family that claimed their son endured years of racial harassment while enrolled at Stissing Mountain Middle/Senior High School.

The White Plains jury announced its verdict last Friday afternoon, March 12, in favor of Henry and Cathleen Zeno, whose son, Anthony, now 21, was at the center of the suit.

“The family was delighted,� said the plaintiff’s attorney, Stephen Bergstein. “The jury believed their son, and the family felt vindicated. The verdict speaks for itself.�

Bergstein confirmed that the jury found the district had not acted quickly enough to address complaints made by Anthony Zeno that he was being racially harassed by students during the more than three years that he attended Stissing Mountain, from January 2005 to June 2008.

The Zenos moved to the town of Pine Plains in 2005 from Long Island, Bergstein said. Anthony’s father is Latino and his mother is white, the attorney explained, and the student was taunted with racial epithets and racially motivated threats, the attorney said.

The district’s Board of Education released a statement on March 13 saying it was “stunned� by the verdict and maintained that the board, administration, faculty and staff in the district “have always given the physical and emotional safety of students the highest priority. There is zero tolerance for racial, or any other form of bullying or harassment, in [the Pine Plains] school community.�

Bergstein countered that while the school did eventually respond to the complaints, it was too late to adequately address the situation.

The jury “saw the pattern we saw, that this kid was undergoing a lot of racial harassment,� he explained. “They thought that if the school responded more quickly that the racial bullying could have stopped.�

A call from this newspaper to district Superintendent Linda Kaumeyer’s office did not patch through to the superintendent, but rather directed one’s attention to the below statement. Kaumeyer herself would not comment.

“The jury in the Zeno v. Pine Plains CSD case found our immediate discipline of students and our sustained cooperation with Dutchess County law enforcement, our student and community training and awareness program (including those of McGrath Systems and Mr. James Childs of JaRa Consulting), our student assembly programs addressing issues of diversity awareness, our conflict resolution and mediation efforts, our character education programs specifically targeting racial issues, our Students and Teachers Opposed to Prejudice (STOP) programs, and our daily, individual work with students, to be insufficient,� the board stated.

It is not clear whether the district will adjust its methods of combating racism and all forms of harassment. However, the board’s statement does say it will continue the programs it had in place and would “continue to utilize professional advice and assistance on the best ways to combat racism and all forms of harassment� in the school district. Towne, Ryan & Partners, the law firm representing the school district, did not respond to requests for a comment on the verdict.

Bergstein said he felt the jury’s decision would “certainly affect� how Pine Plains deals with similar issues in the future.

“It reminds everybody that you need to take this seriously and act quickly,� he said. “I’m sure Pine Plains gets that message, and I think other districts will take a look at their procedures as well.�

Latest News

P&Z approves Victorian bed and breakfast

KENT — Following a public hearing and discussion, the Planning and Zoning Commission (P&Z) at its meeting Thursday, March 14, unanimously approved a special permit application from 81 Victorian Kent for a change of use from boarding house to bed and breakfast.

Wesley Wyrick, P&Z chairman, indicated that the application applied only to the front building, the gingerbread Victorian dating to the 1880s, not to the apartment building in the rear.

Keep ReadingShow less
Stay Informed

Each week The Lakeville Journal and The Millerton News publish a series of newsletters designed to help you stay informed, entertained and engaged with your community.

To subscribe, simply click the button below and select the newsletters you would like to receive. And then, keep an eye on your inbox.

Keep ReadingShow less
Graceful stitching at the altar

An assortment of kneelers and pillows in needlepoint’ there are some done in crewel as well. Note the symbols used throughout the items.

Judith O'Hara Balfe

So much of what we know about religion comes from the written word, but much can be found in paintings, sculptures — and needlework.

Famous tapestries hang in castles and museums around the world, but some of the most beautiful pieces can be found on altars, on kneelers, and in the vestments and hangings found in great cathedrals and in some small country churches.

Keep ReadingShow less
Spanish sonatas and serenades for Easter

José Manuel Gil de Gálvez, left, took a bow with members of the Málaga Chamber Orchestra at The Hotchkiss School Music Center.

Alexander Wilburn

Adding some international vigor to Easter Weekend — or Semana Santa, “The Holy Week,” as it’s known in Spain — The Hotchkiss School held a performance by the Spanish string ensemble the Málaga Chamber Orchestra in the Esther Eastman Music Center on Saturday evening, March 30. Featuring six violins, two violas, two cellos, and a double bass, the chamber music orchestra, which has performed across Europe and the U.S., is led by violinist and Grammy-nominated music producer José Manuel Gil de Gálvez. He has shared the stage with renowned musicians like classical and flamenco guitarist Pepe Romero and South Korean classical cellist Hee-Young Lim and performed at locations like The Berlin Philharmonie, The Laeiszhalle in Hamburg, and The Seoul Arts Center.

With a flamboyant head of long ringlet curls and a mustache/goatee combination reminiscent of Colin Firth’s Elizabethan lord in “Shakespeare in Love,” Gil de Gálvez is a theatrical violinist to take in live, infusing his playing with a passionate performance that heats up lively numbers like the opening Spanish serenade, “Impresiones de España” by 19th-century composer Joaquín Malats. Gil de Gálvez was in full command during his captivating violin solo, “Adiós a la Alhambra” by composer Jesús de Monasterio, who served as honorary violinist of the Capilla Real de Madrid. “Adiós” is an example of de Monasterio’s Alhambrism style, the 19th-century nationalist romantic movement, which, like the contemporary Málaga Chamber Orchestra, was keenly interested in the restoration of music from the Spanish popular heritage.

Keep ReadingShow less