Questions raised about Pine Plains’ affordable housing survey

PINE PLAINS — The Town Board had questions of its own after concerns were raised regarding the recent Affordable Housing Survey that was sent out to all Pine Plains residents. The subject was raised at the Thursday, March 17, Town Board meeting by Carvel Project Development attorney Jennifer Van Tuyl of Cuddy & Feder, LLP. She said her client, Carvel developer Alexander Durst, had expressed doubts the survey was conducted and distributed in an even-handed manner.“It appears some of the surveys were mailed out and others not, or they were mailed out at different times,” she said. “That in itself could be a taint on the survey that can’t be fixed.”The attorney submitted a letter penned by Durst to the Town Board to enter into the records. He referred to the 400 units of affordable housing in New York that The Durst Organization has developed and presently manages and stated the company “stands ready to work with the town in developing the affordable housing program.” He then went on to point to inconsistencies made by the recently formed Affordable Housing Task Force when creating and mailing the 1,500 surveys to Pine Plains residents just this past month.“We understand … that the surveys will arrive with varying types of labeling and postage. These disparities have irrevocably tainted the survey,” Durst wrote, although there were no accusations of intent. “The only remedy at this point is to decline to distribute the remainder of the surveys and wait for an appropriate time interval to allow for a proper survey to be taken.”Durst said he was basing his appeal on advice from pollster Kieran Mahoney of the public affairs firm Mercury. In a letter to Durst, which was also submitted to the Town Board, Mahoney wrote, “It is my professional opinion that the results of this survey will be misleading and unreliable.”Even details like using stamps versus sending letters bulk mail could reportedly elicit different outcomes from respondants. Town Supervisor Gregg Pulver acknowledged the town sent out the surveys with both stamped envelopes and using bulk mail postage. It was also acknowledged that surveys were sent out on different dates, and that as of March 17, residents had received surveys on different days; some said they had yet to receive the survey at all.The Mercury letter, meanwhile, continued to state that all surveys should be based on random sampling. Mahoney criticized the task force’s methodology and its failure to stick to that scientifically established principle. Her key objections to the task force’s survey follow below:“The present survey completely lacks the objectivity of a random survey. The survey is designed to obtain only the opinions of those who choose to respond. Such ‘opt-in’ surveys have been proven to be scientifically unreliable.“There are serious concerns about the questions asked in the survey.… From a survey research standpoint, there is no way to use or analyze data based on the opinions of people who are only identified as someone the anonymous respondent may know. Beyond that, opinions heard second- or third-hand should not be used to formulate public policy.“The survey provides no assurance of authenticity. There is no way to be certain that the person who fills the survey out and sends it back is a resident of Pine Plains, or that a completed survey was sent out at all. The fact that surveys can be mailed back anonymously compounds this problem.”Councilwoman Sandra David, who also serves as liaison between the Town Board and the task force, said the group’s goal was to reach as many people as possible: property owners, renters, voters, non-voters, etc. — more people than those who might merely make up a mailing list or the voters’ registration.Attorney to the Town Warren Replansky weighed in on the matter at the Town Board meeting.“It’s very difficult to produce a flawless survey,” he said before zoning in on one specific complaint — the fact that some residents from neighboring towns received surveys. “The [survey] by the Affordable Housing Task Force may have been sent to some nonresidents of Pine Plains, but it doesn’t hurt to get their input. I think the task force is going to have to understand … it’s going to get some responses from those who may not be residents of Pine Plains.”Pulver said he now appreciates there is more to conducting a survey than he previously realized.“My only concern with the whole thing is this turned into more of a process, and there could have been more checks than there were,” he said. “I thought we were going to talk about it more before the surveys were sent out. I want to make sure the process is a little clearer before the next time.”“The survey was to get a general idea [of where people stand on affordable housing],” David said. “It’s just to give us an idea of what the needs are. This survey was just sort of the beginning of reaching out to the community. We may reach out in other ways. This is to put it on the radar. In other towns people have been very negative [about affordable housing]; we want to get an initial feel of how people are feeling. It’s not an absolute. From there we’re just making a recommendation to the Town Board.”And from there, Replansky said, the town is going to need to implement how the affordable housing requirements are going to be met. He also spoke of the financial reality of the situation.“I don’t think the town is in a position to spend thousands on another survey,” the attorney said.The discussion wrapped up with no clear solutions or recommendations, but there was a parting comment from Councilman Bob Couse.“As far as I’m concerned,” he said about the survey, “something is better than nothing.”

Latest News

South Kent School’s unofficial March reunion

Elmarko Jackson was named a 2023 McDonald’s All American in his senior year at South Kent School. He helped lead the Cardinals to a New England Prep School Athletic Conference (NEPSAC) AAA title victory and was recruited to play at the University of Kansas. This March he will play point guard for the Jayhawks when they enter the tournament as a No. 4 seed against (13) Samford University.

Riley Klein

SOUTH KENT — March Madness will feature seven former South Kent Cardinals who now play on Division 1 NCAA teams.

The top-tier high school basketball program will be well represented with graduates from each of the past three years heading to “The Big Dance.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Hotchkiss grads dancing with Yale

Nick Townsend helped Yale win the Ivy League.

Screenshot from ESPN+ Broadcast

LAKEVILLE — Yale University advanced to the NCAA men’s basketball tournament after a buzzer-beater win over Brown University in the Ivy League championship game Sunday, March 17.

On Yale’s roster this year are two graduates of The Hotchkiss School: Nick Townsend, class of ‘22, and Jack Molloy, class of ‘21. Townsend wears No. 42 and Molloy wears No. 33.

Keep ReadingShow less
Handbells of St. Andrew’s to ring out Easter morning

Anne Everett and Bonnie Rosborough wait their turn to sound notes as bell ringers practicing to take part in the Easter morning service at St. Andrew’s Church.

Kathryn Boughton

KENT—There will be a joyful noise in St. Andrew’s Church Easter morning when a set of handbells donated to the church some 40 years ago are used for the first time by a choir currently rehearsing with music director Susan Guse.

Guse said that the church got the valuable three-octave set when Harlem Valley Psychiatric Center closed in the late 1980s and the bells were donated to the church. “The center used the bells for music therapy for younger patients. Our priest then was chaplain there and when the center closed, he brought the bells here,” she explained.

Keep ReadingShow less
Picasso’s American debut was a financial flop
Picasso’s American debut was a financial flop
Penguin Random House

‘Picasso’s War” by Foreign Affairs senior editor Hugh Eakin, who has written about the art world for publications like The New York Review of Books, Vanity Fair, The New Yorker and The New York Times, is not about Pablo Picasso’s time in Nazi-occupied Paris and being harassed by the Gestapo, nor about his 1937 oil painting “Guernica,” in response to the aerial bombing of civilians in the Basque town during the Spanish Civil War.

Instead, the Penguin Random House book’s subtitle makes a clearer statement of intent: “How Modern Art Came To America.” This war was not between military forces but a cultural war combating America’s distaste for the emerging modernism that had flourished in Europe in the early decades of the 20th century.

Keep ReadingShow less