Al-Kidd case defies immunity defense

In yet another recent, but little noticed case, Al-Kidd v. Ashcroft, the Federal Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled that former Attorney General John Ashcroft could be held personally responsible for his role in promoting the Bush administration policy of misusing the “material witness� statute to arrest and “detain� a U.S. citizen without probable cause.

Abdullah al-Kidd, a U.S. citizen born in Wichita, Kan. (albeit with a “Muslim� name), and a star running back for the University of Idaho, had been previously investigated and found innocent, by the FBI, but was nevertheless arrested after a study visit to Saudi Arabia in 2003, and “detained� under the Federal Material Witness Statute (18 USC sec. 3144). Although there was in fact no real intention ever to use him, and he was never used, as a “material witness� to any other case. It was a device to “detain,� not to seek justice.

u      u      u

The court said: “We are confident that, in the light of the experience of the American colonists with the abuses of the British crown, the Framers of our Constitution would have disagreed with the arrest, detention and harsh confinement of a United States citizen as a ‘material witness.’

“Sadly, however, even now, more than 217 years after ratification of the Fourth Amendment to the Constitution, some confidently assert that the government has the power to arrest and detain or restrict American citizens for months on end, in sometimes primitive conditions, not because there is evidence that they have committed a crime, but merely because the government wishes to investigate them for possible wrongdoing, or to prevent them from having contact with others in the outside world.�

The court concluded: “We find this to be repugnant to the Constitution, and a painful reminder of some of the most ignominious chapters in our national history.�

u      u      u

Ashcroft claimed absolute immunity because, he said, his actions to seek a material witness were those of a government “prosecutor.� He maintained he played no personal role in the Al-Kidd detention. Ashcroft argued he should be immune under a doctrine that guards prosecutors from civil suits. Or so he thought.

The Federal Court did not agree. Ashcroft’s policy was clearly illegal, and accountability extends to those who authorize illegal policies, not just to the “foot soldiers� who carry them out. Illegal advice is a form of illegal engagement.

Ashcroft’s policy was part of a long sequence of illegal advice sought and implemented for and by key members of the Bush administration, at every level in the chain of command. For further details, see “The Torture Memos: Rationalizing the Unthinkable,� by David Cole (New Press, 2009).

The Al-Kidd decision is a clear warning to all those at every level who engaged in illegal detention and torture: Ultimately there is no immunity, institutional or personal, for egregious violations of the U.S. Constitution and U.S. and international human rights law.

Sharon resident Anthony Piel is a former director and legal counsel of the World Health Organization.

Latest News

South Kent School’s unofficial March reunion

Elmarko Jackson was named a 2023 McDonald’s All American in his senior year at South Kent School. He helped lead the Cardinals to a New England Prep School Athletic Conference (NEPSAC) AAA title victory and was recruited to play at the University of Kansas. This March he will play point guard for the Jayhawks when they enter the tournament as a No. 4 seed against (13) Samford University.

Riley Klein

SOUTH KENT — March Madness will feature seven former South Kent Cardinals who now play on Division 1 NCAA teams.

The top-tier high school basketball program will be well represented with graduates from each of the past three years heading to “The Big Dance.”

Keep ReadingShow less
Hotchkiss grads dancing with Yale

Nick Townsend helped Yale win the Ivy League.

Screenshot from ESPN+ Broadcast

LAKEVILLE — Yale University advanced to the NCAA men’s basketball tournament after a buzzer-beater win over Brown University in the Ivy League championship game Sunday, March 17.

On Yale’s roster this year are two graduates of The Hotchkiss School: Nick Townsend, class of ‘22, and Jack Molloy, class of ‘21. Townsend wears No. 42 and Molloy wears No. 33.

Keep ReadingShow less
Handbells of St. Andrew’s to ring out Easter morning

Anne Everett and Bonnie Rosborough wait their turn to sound notes as bell ringers practicing to take part in the Easter morning service at St. Andrew’s Church.

Kathryn Boughton

KENT—There will be a joyful noise in St. Andrew’s Church Easter morning when a set of handbells donated to the church some 40 years ago are used for the first time by a choir currently rehearsing with music director Susan Guse.

Guse said that the church got the valuable three-octave set when Harlem Valley Psychiatric Center closed in the late 1980s and the bells were donated to the church. “The center used the bells for music therapy for younger patients. Our priest then was chaplain there and when the center closed, he brought the bells here,” she explained.

Keep ReadingShow less
Picasso’s American debut was a financial flop
Picasso’s American debut was a financial flop
Penguin Random House

‘Picasso’s War” by Foreign Affairs senior editor Hugh Eakin, who has written about the art world for publications like The New York Review of Books, Vanity Fair, The New Yorker and The New York Times, is not about Pablo Picasso’s time in Nazi-occupied Paris and being harassed by the Gestapo, nor about his 1937 oil painting “Guernica,” in response to the aerial bombing of civilians in the Basque town during the Spanish Civil War.

Instead, the Penguin Random House book’s subtitle makes a clearer statement of intent: “How Modern Art Came To America.” This war was not between military forces but a cultural war combating America’s distaste for the emerging modernism that had flourished in Europe in the early decades of the 20th century.

Keep ReadingShow less